The pauline cafferkey case: what really happened? | nursing times

Nursingtimes

The pauline cafferkey case: what really happened? | nursing times"


Play all audios:

Loading...

After a couple of days of intense media scrutiny the fitness to practise case against Pauline Cafferkey, the nurse who survived ebola, has resulted in her being cleared of all allegations of


misconduct. A hearing panel decided that the virus impaired her judgement when she returned to the UK at the end of 2014 after volunteering in Sierra Leone. The panel said it was due to


illness and exhaustion that she allowed her high temperature to be wrongly recorded – below the threshold for further assessment - at the airport in London and then left the Public Health


England screening area without flagging feeling unwell. For most people, the panel’s conclusion has put an end to any suggestion that Ms Cafferkey acted dishonestly – one of the original


charges that was later dropped – or that she is not fit to practise as a nurse. But what the case has not dealt with is a series of other issues uncovered along the way. > _”A string of 


PHE professionals were involved in testing and > assessing Ms Cafferkey”_ A string of PHE professionals were involved in testing and assessing Ms Cafferkey while she was at the airport


and yet she was still cleared for onward travel back to Scotland. Ms Cafferkey had at some point taken paracetamol – information that was passed between some doctors involved in assessing


her, but not others. This included the one who ended up allowing her to continue her journey after re-testing her temperature a further three times and finding it was only above a normal


range on one reading. Meanwhile, the PHE screening area at the airport was described as “busy, disorganised and even chaotic” and PHE was said to be unprepared for the amount of people


coming back from infected countries. As Ms Cafferkey’s lawyer pointed out in a statement following the conclusion of the hearing, “it is perhaps ironic that given the criticisms made of


Public Health England’s processes it was their complaint that’s led to the NMC investigation and these proceedings being initiated against Pauline”. > _”There is also the mystery of who 


recorded Ms Cafferkey’s wrong > temperature”_ Then there is also the mystery of who recorded Ms Cafferkey’s wrong temperature on the PHE screening form – at which point she, the doctor


taking her temperature, and also another unnamed registrant were present. Ms Cafferkey’s temperature – of more than 38 degrees - was read out to both her and the unnamed registrant but there


is a difference of opinion of what happened next. The doctor said the other registrant stated she would record the temperature as 37.2 degrees – which was lower than the 37.5 threshold - on


the form and they would “get out of here and sort it out”. But Ms Cafferkey said she recalled the words “let’s get out of here” being used but could not remember who said it or who entered


the temperature on her screening form. > _”Ms Cafferkey’s judgement was impaired by this point because > she was ill – but what about the doctor and other registrant?”_ The panel has


now decided Ms Cafferkey’s judgement was impaired by this point because she was ill – but what about the doctor and other registrant? Not only has the case thrown up questions about official


PHE procedures as well as the actions of individual health care workers - and at what point they should be considered accountable as a patient or professional - it has also put the


spotlight on the Nursing and Midwifery Council. Supporters of Ms Cafferkey have questioned why the NMC allowed the case to be brought to this stage in the first place, accusing the regulator


of wasting registrant fees and targeting a nurse who deserved praise – not punishment – after volunteering. But, while there are ongoing discussions about how to improve the efficiency of


the regulator and its dealings with FtP cases, it is of course the NMC’s job to investigate allegations of misconduct. As NMC chief executive Jackie Smith said in a statement, the referral


of the case by PHE included a “highly unusual set of circumstances” which “required a thorough and proper investigation”. And considering the details, criticisms and discrepancies that have


been uncovered in the hearing in the past week, this will probably not be the last investigation stemming from the set of events. MORE ON THIS STORY:


Trending News

Is ken paxton's acquittal a true victory for texas republicans?

Texas' Republican attorney general, Ken Paxton, was acquitted by the state Senate of 16 charges in his recent impea...

Ameliorative effects of probiotics in alcl3-induced mouse model of alzheimer’s disease - applied microbiology and biotechnology

ABSTRACT In recent years, gut microbiome alterations have been linked with complex underlying mechanisms of neurodegener...

See Benedict Cumberbatch Rock a Victorian Cape

See Benedict Cumberbatch Rock a Victorian Cape The Oscar nominee is back to work on Sherlock – and looking hot as usualB...

Tulum festival regrets not having canceled event that spread virus

The organizers of a multi-day festival in Tulum, Quintana Roo, last month — described as a coronavirus  superspreading e...

4 health problems that concern black men

High blood pressure, diabetes, arthritis and heart disease top the list of health conditions concerning Black men 50 and...

Latests News

The pauline cafferkey case: what really happened? | nursing times

After a couple of days of intense media scrutiny the fitness to practise case against Pauline Cafferkey, the nurse who s...

Iron-catalysed synthesis and chemical recycling of telechelic 1,3-enchained oligocyclobutanes

ABSTRACT Closed-loop recycling offers the opportunity to mitigate plastic waste through reversible polymer construction ...

Visualising abscisic acid dynamics at low humidity in planta using abacus2

ABACUS2 FRET biosensors allow an unparalleled live view of the dynamics of the plant hormone abscisic acid in plants. We...

Adweek

Editor’s Picks THE ADWEEK RESOURCE LIBRARY Be a better marketer and get access to the latest Adweek-created guides, excl...

Novel chemoimmunotherapeutic strategy for hepatocellular carcinoma based on a genome-wide association study

ABSTRACT Pharmacotherapeutic options are limited for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Recently, we identified the anti-tu...

Top