A response to Ramjas College’s Dhani Ram Ambedkar’s ‘gurukul’ statement
A response to Ramjas College’s Dhani Ram Ambedkar’s ‘gurukul’ statement"
Play all audios:
Ramjas College has made it to the radar of media houses and has turned into discursive field, yet again. This time around, it is for one Assistant Professor of Commerce Department, Dhani Ram
Ambedkar, who voiced his opinion about how the college has “seemingly started taking precautions to avert such incidents, and have decided to adopt ‘Gurukul’ style teaching to freshers who
will join this year.” The statement was retracted by the college authorities today, yet the nuanced solutions and important suggestions of Dhani Ram Ambedkar need a comprehensive analysis
and material contextualisation in the events of the college from where his ideas and problematic solution emerge.
The “problem” that Dhaniram refers to is the violent attacks on February 21 and 22 against students who got together to organise an annual seminar, Cultures of Protest, a two-day programme
to grapple with ideas and seek for solutions of complex issues to do with exploitation and protest in the country. However, there is a twist there. The understanding of the “problem” is
flawed as it considers the violence to be a result of “provocation” by the organisers, a result of the “mistakes” committed by the organising committee in inviting Umar Khalid and Shehla
Rashid to speak on topics in which they are experts. When the narrative is constructed upside down so that the problem becomes the debate and not the brutal violence, then the ‘the
solutions’, too, cannot be straightforward. I shall first try and look into Dhani Ram’s proposed solution and their pragmatic relevance, examine their impact and then look into the moral
connotations of the interview.
The first part of his solution to end disruption in college is to stop “unlawful assembly” in the premises. How does a teacher in a college disregard the very ethos of a university space? A
space which has been created specifically for thinking minds to debate and discuss. The “discipline” that he proposes is in complete contradiction to the idea of a university . In the most
horrific and brutal manner, it is an attempt to now limit and circumscribe the physical space of students, after the already heavy surveillance on and the diminishing space for ideas and
thinking. How does one determine this “unlawful assembly”? Is it a group of students in a class, the canteen or a bunch of students talking in the college, or are these all “unlawful”? Where
do we draw a line? How many students will be considered an ‘unlawful assembly’? Is he seriously considering implementing Section 144 on a permanent basis inside a college?
The second part of his solution is that the students must not slip into “activism”. He says, “They (the students) should concentrate on their attendance rather than get into activism…” His
attempt is clearly to alienate us, the students of the university, from speaking about issues that touch us the most, that affect us in our everyday-lives. The attempt to curtail our
fundamental right to speak for what we feel and what is right and wrong is an attack on the foundations of a democratic society. How do we ask students of a University reading Edward. W.
Said who said, “Above all, authority can, indeed must, be analyzed.” not to question the ones who destabilise their rights? But, Dhani Ram is not content with simply silencing us in the
public sphere: he wants to control our emotions in the private sphere as well. He dictates that students should not get into personal relationships either. The future citizen that he wants
to create through this gurukul style of teaching is an unthinking, unfeeling, uncritical person.
This is an attempt to stab student movements across country, to control the wind of change that is rising and gathering power to question the ones in power. University education is about
activism: it is about being aware of one’s rights and privileges, about understanding oppression and questioning the oppressor, about trying to make a nation that is a space where each and
every citizen can exist with dignity and equality. To stop activism in colleges is like throwing fish out of water—usurping life, forcing them to die and rot. The most disturbing part is the
ideological undertone that this diktat carries: the binary of “national” and “anti-national”. This is the lens to see and understand everything under in the country today. Simply singing
the national anthem every morning unthinkingly is to be a marker of one’s nationalist sentiments. Those who want to make the nation a better place for all its citizens by questioning
inequality and exploitation become threats to the society.
In this heavily moralistic sermon, there is a compulsion to sing national anthems to prove nationalist sentiments. The nationalism, therefore, is very symbolic in nature. Any attempt to
further act on the sentiments for any productive purposes gets one into the trouble zone. Going back to the seminar once again, the attempt to understand the problems of this country and
trying to work towards a solution became an act of “anti-national”. This can be seen in the fact that the college authorities have failed grandly in punishing anyone who had engaged in the
violent attacks inside the college premises, that left the country shocked. The inability to redress the grievances of the victims in a timely manner when there is plenty of evidence
establishing the facts very clearly attests to this. The true solution to the actual problem of perpetration of violence by a gang of students is immediate action against the perpetrators of
violence who move scot free. It is devastating to see the solution to violence in the “Gurukul model” and “national anthem”. It seems the time has come when we have gau-rakshaks and
anti-romeo-squads inside our college campuses who are now dictating terms about how we must talk, think, eat or maybe just live, if at all we can!
Trending News
Yashasvi jaiswal, the ambitious allahabadi, is here to stayWhen 13-year-old Yashasvi Jaiswal came to Mumbai from Allahabad four years back, he never thought his dream to play cric...
Shivalayam: పొలం దున్నుతుండగా సడెన్గా ఆగిపోయిన ఎద్దులు.. అక్కడ తవ్వి చూసి బిత్తరపోయారు..!CNN18 name, logo and all associated elements ® and © 2017 Cable News Network LP, LLLP. A Time Warner Company. All rights...
Ind vs aus 4th test : ఆస్ట్రేలియాతో నాలుగో టెస్టు.. టీమిండియాలో భారీ మార్పులు.. తుది జట్టు ఇదేటీమిండియా తుది జట్టు(అంచనా) : రోహిత్ శర్మ (కెప్టెన్), జైస్వాల్, కేఎల్ రాహుల్, గిల్, విరాట్ కోహ్లీ, రిషభ్ పంత్, రవీంద్ర జ...
India’s First Underwater Metro | దేశంలోనే మొట్టమొదటి నీటి అడుగున నడిచే మెట్రోTelugu Edition हिन्दी(Hindi) English(English) বাংলা(Bengali) मराठी(Marathi) ગુજરાતી(Gujarati) অসমীয়া(Assam) ಕನ್ನಡ(Kanna...
Pawan kalyan: తునిలో పవన్ కళ్యాణ్ ఎన్నికల ప్రచారంCNN18 name, logo and all associated elements ® and © 2017 Cable News Network LP, LLLP. A Time Warner Company. All rights...
Latests News
A response to Ramjas College’s Dhani Ram Ambedkar’s ‘gurukul’ statementRamjas College has made it to the radar of media houses and has turned into discursive field, yet again. This time aroun...
Andhra's private bus operators hit out at MP Kesineni Nani over Arunachal crackdownPrivate bus operators in Telangana and Andhra lashed out against the state government's 'ban' on some of their vehicles,...
Hd deve gowda to contest rajya sabha polls from karnataka; bjp nominates eranna kadadi, ashok gastiThe election is scheduled on June 19 to fill four Rajya Sabha seats from Karnataka which will fall vacant on June 25. Fo...
Congress leader Botsa Satyanarayana admits defeat in SeemandhraA day before the counting of votes polled in the Lok Sabha election, a senior Congress leader on Thursday admitted the p...
Ap grama sachivalayam recruitment 2019: more than 1. 60 lakh vacancies in andhra pradesh, apply hereHere are all the necessary details for the application to AP Grama Sachivalayam Recruitment 2019. The Andhra Pradesh gov...