Montana wildfires reignite logging debate

Wfae

Montana wildfires reignite logging debate"


Play all audios:

Loading...

AILSA CHANG, HOST: Montana has had one of the worst wildfire seasons in decades. It's ended in large part because of rain and early snows. Before that, two firefighters died on the job.


The state spent nearly $380,000,000 trying to suppress the fires. Still going strong is a debate over logging and the role it should play in preventing fires. Montana Public Radio's


Eric Whitney reports. ERIC WHITNEY, BYLINE: Montanans got used to the sound of firefighting air tankers passing overhead this summer, going to drop load after load of water and retardant on


dozens of fires. (SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING) UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Secretary Zinke and Secretary Perdue, thank you for being here. This is... WHITNEY: President Trump's secretaries of


Agriculture and Interior visited a scene like that in August at the invitation of the Republicans in Montana's congressional delegation. In a valley choked with thick smoke from


several area forest fires, Congressman Greg Gianforte told them that things wouldn't be this bad if federal land managers had freer rein to log forests and remove trees from federal


land. (SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING) GREG GIANFORTE: We're tied up in knots through extensive and ridiculous permitting processes and frivolous lawsuits from environmental


extremists. WHITNEY: Gianforte said those, quote, "extremists" were directly to blame for a big fire burning nearby. (SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING) GIANFORTE: There was a


project there that the Forest Service worked together with the community and the county commissioners called the Stonewall Project. And it took eight years to get that forest management


project approved only to have a single judge overturn it. And now that forest is burning. WHITNEY: The project to reduce fire danger by cutting down and removing trees from a couple of


thousand acres of national forest land was put on hold by a judge in May in response to a lawsuit from a pair of environmental groups. They said it would harm habitat for endangered grizzly


bears and lynx. Two months later, lightning started a fire that would eventually burn 18,000 acres, including part of the Stonewall project area. But not everyone sees the cause and effect


Congressman Gianforte does. ANDREW LARSON: The environmentalists are not responsible for that fire burning. And had the Stonewall Project advanced, it's very likely that the site would


be burning today. WHITNEY: Andrew Larson is a professor of forest ecology at the University of Montana. He and others in his department say that in a drought year like this one in Montana,


even if the trees had been removed, the vegetation left behind still would have burned. Ecologists say it's well-established that a warming climate means fire seasons are getting longer


and more intense in the American West, so stopping wildfires is an unrealistic goal. LARSON: What we might be able to achieve is areas that don't burn with as high a severity. We might


also have safer working environments for fire managers. WHITNEY: That sounds like a good goal to the man in charge of the U.S. Forest Service, Agriculture Secretary Sonny Perdue. He's


not ready to tie climate change to human activity. But he says... (SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING) SONNY PERDUE: There obviously is climate change, temperature change and weather change.


And we have to deal with that. We have to adapt to it. And we have to manage the forest getting ahead of that. WHITNEY: Which takes us back to conservative lawmakers' frustration with


lawsuits that stop timber sales. Green groups say the sales are only being stopped if they violate environmental laws. Members of Congress from western states have long pitched legislation


to make logging public lands easier. With the House, Senate and White House all in Republican hands, now may be their best opportunity to do so in years. For NPR News, I'm Eric Whitney


in Missoula, Mont. [POST-BROADCAST CORRECTION: In the introduction to this story, we say Montana spent nearly $380 million fighting wildfires. The state actually spent $50 million; the


balance came from other sources.] (SOUNDBITE OF SEA WOLF SONG, "YOU'RE A WOLF") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.


Trending News

Vanguard eur eurozone government 1-3 year bond ucits etf eur accumulating - eur, cours tracker vsgf, cotation bourse euronext amsterdam

L'information la moins chère... depuis toujours. Vous avez choisi de ne pas accepter les cookies. Chez Boursorama, ...

Seven reasons nordic walking is better for you than the normal kind

Have you ever noticed people out walking with poles even on flat surfaces and wondered why they are doing it? This is kn...

Heads up: slingplayer mobile for palm os now available | techcrunch

Those of you who top-rock a Treo 700p should take note that SlingPlayer for Palm OS is now available for download to the...

Doctor numbers decline in france

THE NUMBER OF DOCTORS IN FRANCE HAS DROPPED FOR THE FIRST TIME IN 25 YEARS THE NUMBER of doctors in France has dropped f...

Hours after being caught taking a bribe, telangana official jumps to death

 A government official in Telangana committed suicide on Saturday, hours after he was caught red-handed while taking a b...

Latests News

Montana wildfires reignite logging debate

AILSA CHANG, HOST: Montana has had one of the worst wildfire seasons in decades. It's ended in large part because o...

Iran rejects west's demand to ship out uranium stockpiles

 Iran on Sunday rejected the West's demand that it send sensitive nuclear material out of the country but signalled...

Lakers 115, Hornets 111 (OT) - Los Angeles Times

Sports Lakers 115, Hornets 111 (OT) Lakers guard Kobe Bryant is fouled on a layup in the final minute of overtime by Hor...

Angry at #showyourbrastrap campaign, breast cancer survivors instead show scars

Speaking to doctors, Asian Age quoted Dr Vijay Anand Reddy, director of Apollo Cancer Hospital saying, “Having models an...

Birmingham airport 'in discussions' to reintroduce direct us routes

BIRMINGHAM AIRPORT BOSS NICK BARTON HAS RESPONDED TO HINTS THAT DELTA, BIRMINGHAM CITY FOOTBALL CLUB'S SPONSOR, COU...

Top