Uk drug policy: how seizing passports will not stop illicit dug use

Theconversation

Uk drug policy: how seizing passports will not stop illicit dug use"


Play all audios:

Loading...

In an attempt to clamp down on recreational drug use, the British government recently set out a three-tier system for dealing with people caught in possession of illegal substances. A scale


of punishments would be introduced for those caught in possession once, twice or three times. These would begin with a fine and culminate in a variety of deeply punitive options such as


tagging offenders, suspending their driving licence and even confiscating their passport. All this is being promoted as part of a government plan, entitled Swift, Certain, Tough: new


consequences for drug possession, which aims to bring overall drug use down to “a historic 30-year low” by “delivering a generational shift in demand”. Other nations, including the US,


Jamaica and Thailand are modernising their drug policies and moving away from criminalisation. The UK, meanwhile, seems determined to disregard the evidence that has for decades contradicted


the idea that ever-tougher responses are needed. Research has long shown that punitive measures are not a deterrent. Further, most illegal drug use is recreational, more commonly associated


with leisure and pleasure than criminality. Research shows that recreational drug use rarely leads to addiction or requires treatment. The government seems far from understanding this, as


is evident when it calls drugs the “root of untold harm and misery across our society” in its reform proposals. It is questionable whether this reductionist discourse applies to any drug


user – there are, for example, functioning heroin addicts who live normal productive lives – let alone recreational drugs and their users. Evidence shows criminalising otherwise law-abiding


citizens for their drug use does not deter them from doing it. In fact, it merely serves to damage their life chances We know that a conviction makes it harder for people (and particularly


young people) to find housing, get a job and travel. It also makes them more likely to continue offending. All this should make the government think long and hard about which offences


therefore justify serious punishment. PUNITIVE MEASURES ARE DISCRIMINATORY IN PRACTICE Drug laws and their punishments are not applied equitably and tend to discriminate along the lines of


class, and gender, as we have already seen with cannabis warnings. Cannabis warnings are issued by the police for those found in possession of a small amount of cannabis and operate as the


first stage of a similar three-tiered escalation system implemented to deal with cannabis use. And when it comes to race, they discriminate too. In London, black people, often from deprived


areas, receive cannabis warnings at three times the rate of white people. Law enforcement measures are being used to deter recreational drug use, while more harmful substances such as


alcohol, tobacco and sugar remain legal and socially acceptable. This, despite the research being clear on how such substances cause more harm than many of their illicit counterparts. A


truly evidence-based approach to drugs would look very different. The proposed new “three-tier” approach may appear to be a reform but the reality is that while the government’s proposed


punishments for first and second offences may appear to err towards decriminalisation, the punishments for third offences – tagging offenders, suspending their driving licences and


confiscating their passports – are extreme. Ultimately, this remains a law enforcement approach that has already been shown to be ineffective. It will not bring overall drug use down. It


will, however, undoubtedly cause untold harm to thousands of people. Instead of focusing on low-level possession of recreational drugs, we need realistic, effective, evidence-based ways to


reduce the harms of drugs, in terms of use and supply. We also need to support those drug users who want support, rather than inflicting punishments that will disproportionately criminalise


certain groups of users.


Trending News

Boris johnson’s brexit tax cuts plea rejected by theresa may

Income tax, stamp duty and capital gains tax should all be reduced without rises in other levies, Mr Johnson said. His c...

How to sell your home to foreigners

WHETHER it is a country house or a town flat, a property that has huge appeal to a Briton might not appeal at all to a F...

Download the lab’s iphone app

[embedded content]The world of journalism is changing faster than ever. Want to keep on top of every new business model,...

Premier league: latest news, news articles, photos, videos - newsbytes

Manchester City have completed the signing of Dutch midfielder Tijjani Reijnders from AC Milan for a fee of £46.3 millio...

Government has 'absolutely no plans' to scrap free bus pass

The UK Government has "absolutely no plans to withdraw the concessionary bus pass scheme" for those over State...

Latests News

Uk drug policy: how seizing passports will not stop illicit dug use

In an attempt to clamp down on recreational drug use, the British government recently set out a three-tier system for de...

Prime minister narendra modi seeks a smooth parliament session

Presides over an all-party meet, urges all members to deliver on the people's expectation from both Houses Prime Mi...

‘wise to assume bird flu pandemic will cause more severe disease in humans than covid-19’

H5N1, or bird flu, has been perceived as a potential public health threat for at least 20 years now, since the virus inf...

Breast fed children enjoy reduced risk of diabetes

They studied 334,553 deliveries during the 24-year period in Manitoba province involving 60,088 FN births and 274,465 no...

How bmw aims to outsell other luxury makes

Ludwig Willisch took over as president of BMW of North America at a fortuitous time. The German native joined the compan...

Top