Grattan on friday: abbott should step down in favour of turnbull

Theconversation

Grattan on friday: abbott should step down in favour of turnbull"


Play all audios:

    

When Malcolm Turnbull appeared at Thursday night’s politics in the pub on the NSW central coast the first questioner demanded to know whether he was interested in being leader. Turnbull


dodged around but he was particularly anxious to stress one point. Tony Abbott had had “more consistency and loyalty from the frontbench than any other Liberal leader in our lifetime”. The


subtext was: the crisis in which Abbott is engulfed is not because he’s been undermined by colleagues – it’s his own work. No-one knows what will happen when the Liberals gather on Tuesday –


whether the meeting will be a fizzer, a fizz or a boilover; whether the critics will retreat or move on their embattled leader, or the outcome if they do move. So let’s put aside the


impossible job of prediction, and consider what might be best for the party. This rests on a judgement about whether Abbott can revive sufficiently for the government to be competitive or


better at next year’s election. It’s hard to see it. If Abbott survives in the short term, it’s quite likely he’ll be kicked out later. If the party baulked at execution, on present


indications the voters would undertake the task. We know leaders can rebuild but there is such an entrenched view of Abbott among voters that, on the balance of probabilities, he can’t climb


back – just as it was clear well out from the 2013 election that Julia Gillard couldn’t. In these circumstances, the best option would be an orderly leadership transition, with Abbott


stepping down. Abbott would resist this: he’s a natural fighter and it would be an inglorious end. But it would be an honourable act for his party, which would resent having to blast Abbott


out, and remember him badly if he cost it the election. Importantly, a voluntary exit would ensure his successor did not arrive blood-splattered. Then there’s the matter of timing. Those


trying to contain the feral backbenchers leading the anti-Abbott campaign say “he deserves more time”. Maybe, but at what cost? The federal crisis is likely to bleed into the late March NSW


election, which is already tightening. How much of a handicap Abbott will be to Premier Mike Baird’s campaign can’t be known. But if Baird had a narrow scrape, Abbott would get some blame


and it would trigger another crisis, with NSW federal marginal seat holders in a panic. If Abbott is terminal, it would be better to have the matter resolved quickly, for the sake of the


Baird government. To have it over soon would also be helpful for the Coalition’s second budget. A new prime minister later in the year would inherit an Abbott-Hockey budget rather than


selling the product of the fresh team. And who should comprise that team? The option (canvassed by some in the party) of Malcolm Turnbull as prime minister and Scott Morrison as treasurer,


with Julie Bishop remaining deputy Liberal leader and foreign minister would seem the best combination. Turnbull is strong on economics, and popular in the community. Bishop is also


well-liked and many female voters would warm to her. But she does not have the grunt for the economic debate that a prime minister needs; she is not a policy innovator. One grudgingly


advocates Morrison, who’s shown a heart of ice towards the human rights of asylum seekers, as Joe Hockey’s replacement. But he has ability and – probably – the talent to carry the budget


argument. With longer term leadership aspirations (he’d lack the numbers now) he’ll be anxious to remake his image. Morrison as treasurer would also be a bone to the right from the moderate


Turnbull. There is no doubt that Turnbull would be a major risk. We’ve seen him as Liberal leader before and he performed badly. It wasn’t just his problems around carbon pricing, although


they brought things to a head, or the fact he believed a Treasury official who had faked an email (understandable, given the man’s seniority). Turnbull’s troubles lay in his personal flaws,


including his often dismissive attitude to others and his short attention span. These were on show as much as his intelligence and wit. As his colleagues know, there is the charming Malcolm


and the dark Malcolm. Leaders who look to resurrection – John Howard, Kevin Rudd – will say they’ve changed. Howard had changed a lot, Rudd not much at all. Only the test of office would


tell if Turnbull had sufficiency re-minted himself. But he’s seen the precedents, and he’d have an enormous amount at stake. Turnbull would have to bring the Liberals together, which most


obviously would mean managing the issue of climate policy. Those in the party who feel strongly against him on this are intense about it. He’s begun work on the challenge, and it is worth


quoting his rationale at length. Leaving Thursday night’s function Turnbull was asked by a reporter whether he had recently changed his position. He replied: “No, let me be quite clear about


it. An emissions trading scheme is a tool, it is an economic tool, to reduce emissions. It’s not the only tool, there are many different approaches you could take. It’s not a question of


ideology, it’s just a mechanism, right. "Now we had a referendum on the emissions trading scheme in 2013 which was concluded, or resolved, decisively against one. It was then repealed.


It was replaced by the Direct Action policy. Now some people have said, ‘you know, Malcolm doesn’t agree with the government’s policy and it should be changed’. "But let me say this to


you: You can’t change your policies every two years or every three years. My own view is that we have got the same target, it’s a bipartisan target, but we have got a different mechanism. We


have got to work with that, leave that as it is. And as is consistent with our Liberal policy, in the event of there being a new global agreement we will review that existing policy.


"But the idea that we would or should suddenly reinstate something we’ve just abolished is ridiculous. I mean, business needs stability and continuity. So the law’s been changed, it


should be left as it is. And then like any law, it will be reviewed down the track if and when there is a new global agreement. So you know, it’s just common sense.” There’d be many other


problems for Turnbull, including managing a reshuffle and dealing with the party organisation (when he was leader, he reportedly wanted to get rid of federal director Brian Loughnane). All


in all, a move to Turnbull would be no cakewalk. But unfortunately for the Liberals the Abbott prime ministership has turned sour as a lemon.


Trending News

Sriram balaji becomes first indian army man to qualify for wimbledon

Meanwhile, Ankita Raina, who was bidding to become the first Indian woman to feature in the Women's singles categor...

Page not found - Behind The News

Sorry, page not found This might be because:The page you were looking for was removed, had its name changed, or is tempo...

Gearing up for Bt cotton

ANDHRA Pradesh, the state where more than 500 farmers committed suicide after a failed crop in 1998, is now set to offic...

Disposal of endosulfan begins

KERALA has started disposing of expired stocks of endosulfan. A task force, chaired by deputy collector of Kasaragod dis...

US led coalition stages 31 air strikes on Islamic State: Joint Task Force

Seven of the attacks were near the Iraqi city of Fallujah and hit bridges, a bomb-making facility and other targets. The...

Latests News

San francisco earthquake: was bay area hit by earthquake just now?

There have been upwards of 15 tremors over the last day in East Bay, according to figures from the United States Geologi...

Grattan on friday: abbott should step down in favour of turnbull

When Malcolm Turnbull appeared at Thursday night’s politics in the pub on the NSW central coast the first questioner dem...

Take stereotypes out of text books

SCHOOL text books should stop reinforcing stereotypes, an anti-discrimination body has said.La Halde, Haute autorité de ...

AARP Livability Fact Sheet: Road Diets

Facebook Twitter Most drivers base their travel speed on what feels comfortable given the street design. The wider the r...

Miller, Cammalleri to Make Their Debuts

OTTAWA — One familiar and one not, two players will join the Kings’ lineup for the first time this season for tonight’s ...

Top