Charter schools: fabulous or failures?

Theconversation

Charter schools: fabulous or failures?"


Play all audios:

Loading...

Depending on who you ask, charter schools may be either an important solution to persistent educational inequality, or a misguided attack on public schools as Americans know them. Both sides


are firmly entrenched in this debate, which remains one the more polarizing arguments in American education. But what does the evidence actually say? The truth about charter schools is, as


with many areas of public policy, somewhere in between. Part of the difficulty in characterizing what experts know about charter schools is that it depends on the question we are asking. For


supporters and opponents alike, the first question concerns performance: are the academic outcomes of students attending charter schools higher or lower than those in the traditional public


sector? One very recent study, using sophisticated statistical techniques to summarize dozens of analyses across many states and cities, found that charter schools generally outperform


traditional public schools in math, with little difference between the two sectors in reading. Studies that account for student background by assigning charter seats on the basis of


applicant lotteries–research generally considered the gold standard for social science–have provided some of the strongest evidence for positive charter effects. But if the bulk of the


evidence available suggests modest, positive charter advantages for student achievement, this kind of bird’s eye view can mask important variation in the way charters operate nationwide. One


recent study of schools in 27 states containing 95 percent of the nation’s charter students found charter advantages overall, but not necessarily in every state: reading scores were


actually higher for traditional public school students in eight of the 27 states, and math scores higher in 13 out of 27 states. Similarly, a new lottery-based study across 13 states found


no significant advantage for charter students. Such differences are at least partly due to differences in state laws defining what constitutes a charter school. WHO BENEFITS AND WHO LOSES?


Moreover, student achievement is not the only question under consideration in the charter debate. There is new evidence that charter schools’ impact on educational attainment – high school


graduation or college enrollment – are positive and substantial, perhaps more so than on student test scores. There may, however, be other impacts that are less desirable. A number of


researchers have found evidence that students in charter schools are more racially segregated than their traditional public peers. There is also the question of which students benefit from


high-performing charters. Although some studies have found that disadvantaged students may benefit the most from charter schooling, one prominent critique claims that charter schools succeed


by avoiding the most challenging students, including low achievers or students with special needs. And do charter schools have an overall effect on students who remain in traditional


schools? School districts may suffer net financial losses to charter schools and, although some supporters have argued that competitive pressures from charters can force public schools to


improve their own performance, the evidence for such outcomes is unclear. The answer then to the question of whether charter schools provide opportunities for students in struggling public


schools appears to be “yes, but…” The important word here is “opportunity.” For some students, attending certain charter schools may lead to significant improvements in their educational


experiences. How those effects occur remains a matter for debate; explanations for charter successes and failures are as varied as the results themselves. A careful and balanced appraisal of


the charter school picture would recognize the potential that charters hold for students in some settings, while acknowledging that for most communities, the bulk of our social and economic


investments remain in the traditional public sector.


Trending News

Cyclone pam aid efforts should keep future disasters in mind

The immediate focus following natural disasters such as Cyclone Pam, which has devastated Vanuatu, is almost always on t...

Hrodna azot strike committee reveals details of accident

10 * 19.04.2021, 22:33 * 30,996__ Several workshops have come to a standstill. Members of the Hrodna Azot striking commi...

DWP PIP axe update as 'over 40s' and 'back pain' to bear brunt details emerge

NewsDWP PIP axe update as 'over 40s' and 'back pain' to bear brunt details emergeNew details have emerged about which sp...

Lawmakers in congress take on same-sex marriage and a potential rail strike

A MARTÍNEZ, HOST: Congress is deep into its lame-duck session, a chance for lawmakers to finish business from earlier in...

When making thanksgiving dressing, grandma monnette had one simple rule

UPDATED NOVEMBER 21, 2023 AT 5:24 AM ET _All Things We're Cooking is an NPR series that features family recipes fro...

Latests News

Charter schools: fabulous or failures?

Depending on who you ask, charter schools may be either an important solution to persistent educational inequality, or a...

‘passionate person who loved cinema’: film industry, fans offer tributes to kaushik lm

Riaz Ahmed, public relations officer to Rajinikanth, said, “Unable to comprehend this, as I met him just day before … go...

Mobiles with 6000mah battery: for those who want best endurance for their handset | - the times reviews

Image Source: Pexels.com Irrespective of what features you are looking for in a smartphone, long battery life comes as a...

Former cabarrus county schools high school coach arrested for indecent liberties with a minor

A former Cabarrus County high school softball coach was arrested yesterday on charges of indecent liberties with a minor...

Three animals that can detect disease in humans

When it comes to accurately diagnosing a disease, you might think you need expensive, high-tech machinery and equipment ...

Top