How brexit politicised the civil service | thearticle

Thearticle

How brexit politicised the civil service | thearticle"


Play all audios:

Loading...

Before becoming a lawyer, I was a civil servant: at the end of the 90s I worked as an EU official for over a decade. While I had admired the spirit of public service since I was little, in


my country, Spain, the administration was — and still is — heavily politicised. The same was true in Brussels, where it was almost impossible to make a career at the EU institutions without


the right political backing. During my time at the EU, we looked up to the UK Civil Service as the “crème de la crème”. Most politicians only like to hear from those who agree with them, so


at the EU we hesitated about warning our political masters that they had disregarded something important or got something wrong. But we were told that in the UK even young officials could


make their views known to Ministers without the fear of any negative repercussions. UK civil service jobs were not given or taken away on political grounds and therefore officials were


insulated from political games. It seemed like nirvana to all of us. Neil Kinnock was sent to Brussels as Commissioner to try to reform the EU administration along the British model. Though


he tried hard to get all officials to behave more like the Brits, he did not manage to make much progress. It was indeed a difficult task. But the narrative about the superiority of the


British administration endured: UK officials were considered not just above average, but at the very top of the European game. I then went to work at the Foreign Office in the Middle East


department led by Mark Sedwill. As often happens, the reality did not quite live up to the image I had in my mind. The Foreign Office was impeccably smooth and well-organised, but it had a


crippling inability to address new challenges. While the shambolic nature of the EU administration allowed room for good civil servant teams to run with innovative proposals, the UK’s


stringent procedures killed any originality. Still, what stood out to me above anything else was the quality of the upper layer of the UK civil service: they were there not because of their


political allegiance, but on the basis of meritocracy and impartiality; as a result, with very few exceptions, they had an unwavering commitment to both excellence and public service ethics.


Fast forward twenty years and the once unparalleled reputation of the UK administration is now in tatters. The reason? The way in which pro-Brexit ideology trumps anything else for the UK


Conservative government, including the impartiality and meritocracy of the civil service The first sign of the decline came when, just after David Cameron lost the Brexit referendum in 2016,


the government made no attempt to bring back to the UK administration the EU officials of British nationality who had been until then working in Brussels. Doing so would have put the UK in


a truly advantageous position to negotiate the Brexit deal — what could be better than having people on your team who have been working for the other side? But the very fact these people had


worked in Brussels made them, in the Government’s view, off-limits and quasi-pariahs. The second sign was when Theresa May forced the UK ambassador to the EU, Sir Ivan Rogers, to resign. He


was a widely respected man who had loyally worked for politicians of all stripes. But Theresa May, an insecure Prime Minister, saw his impartiality as a personal affront, so he was


side-lined — this is exactly what happens to impartial senior civil servants in countries like mine where the administration is heavily politicised. The final blow took place last week, when


the Head of the Civil Service, Sir Mark Sedwill, was forced to resign to make way for an ardent Brexiteer. He was replaced as National Security Adviser by David Frost. Frost was chosen for


his loyalty to the Brexit cause as, unbelievably for a job with such crucial responsibilities, he has zero experience on security matters. Instead of being known for his competence and


impartiality, as his predecessor was, Frost is known for being, in the words of Lord John Kerr for whom he worked for many years, “extremely diligent in doing what he is told”. Boris


Johnson, Dominic Cummins and Michael Gove often speak of the need to “reform” the civil service, but all they are doing is crudely and blatantly politicising it. The government could


legitimately try to bring in more technical expertise, to make the administration more diverse, or to modernise it — but instead No 10 is indoctrinating the administration with its own


political ideology. All around Europe we used to admire the UK Civil Service for its quality and impartiality, but the UK government has made that no longer possible. By politicising the


administration, they have diminished the international standing of the country.


Trending News

Private sector must help achieve 'hunger free' india: g20 sherpa

NEW DELHI: The country's G20 Sherpa Amitabh Kant on Wednesday called for greater private sector participation to en...

Let's learn | wordsville: the case with no questions | season 2024

- Did a word that's important to you go missing? - And now all you can feel, do, or think is the opposite of that w...

South Korean navy patrol plane crashes in country’s south, killing 4

SEOUL:  A South Korean navy plane crashed during a training flight on Thursday, killing all four crew members on board, ...

Deepika padukone breaks silence with after 'spirit' exit sparks online row

Meanwhile, director Sandeep Reddy Vanga took to social media platform X (formerly Twitter) on May 26 with a pointed post...

Bbmp begins native sapling plantation drive at lakes, parks; aims to plant one lakh trees this year

BENGALURU: With early monsoon and a friendly environment for plantation drive, the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (B...

Latests News

How brexit politicised the civil service | thearticle

Before becoming a lawyer, I was a civil servant: at the end of the 90s I worked as an EU official for over a decade. Whi...

Nature - volume 145 issue 3684, 8 june 1940

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best expe...

George clooney on living a life that fills your heart

Memorial Day Sale! Join AARP for just $11 per year with a 5-year membership Join now and get a FREE gift. Expires 6/4  G...

Sampling environmental dna from trees and soil to detect cryptic arboreal mammals

ABSTRACT Environmental DNA (eDNA) approaches to monitoring biodiversity in terrestrial environments have largely focused...

Politics | The Guardian

Print subscriptions Sign in My account Account overview Billing Profile Emails & marketing Data privacy Settings Help Co...

Top