Senate republicans approve trump court nominee sight unseen

Nymag

Senate republicans approve trump court nominee sight unseen"


Play all audios:

Loading...

Photo: Sarah Silbiger/Getty Images Last night, less than three days after Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s sudden death, a gleeful Lindsey Graham announced that Republican senators had the votes to


replace her. “We’ve got the votes to confirm Justice Ginsburg’s replacement before the election,” he said on Fox News. “We’re going to move forward in the committee, we’re going to report


the nomination out of the committee to the floor of the United States Senate so we can vote before the election.” Ten years ago, when the House of Representatives passed the Affordable Care


Act, the main Republican point of contention was that the process had moved too fast. Every Republican talking point attacking the bill denounced the method of its passage as having been


“rammed through” or “jammed down our throats” at “lightning speed.” (The law was, in fact, crafted over the span of nearly a year and entailed dozens of hours of public testimony.) A


secondary point of outrage was that, even though 60 senators had passed it, the Senate used a 50-vote reconciliation bill to smooth out differences between the two bills. The notion that


such a large social change would be implemented without minority party buy-in added to the indignation. Here, the upper chamber has decided to approve President Trump’s nominee for a


lifetime appointment on a court that — unlike courts in many other countries — has supreme power of judicial review. Unlike a health-care law, which can be repealed if people don’t like it,


it is impossible to recall a confirmed Supreme Court justice barring a constitutional amendment. The Senate has held zero hearings to assess the nominee’s fitness, independence, or


viewpoint. Most comically, they have rounded up the votes without even knowing the justice’s identity. If you remember the Obamacare debate, Nancy Pelosi said, “We have to pass the bill so


that you can find out what is in it — away from the fog of the controversy.” Pelosi was actually trying to say that Republican distortions had made it impossible for Americans to understand


what the law actually did, and once they saw it in action, they would approve of it. (She was right about that.) They distorted the quote, always excising the last clause, to imply she was


trying to smuggle details into law before Congress could learn what the law did. But here, Republican senators have done exactly that! They have secured 50 votes to confirm a


justice-to-be-named-later to a lifetime appointment — one that, along with four like-minded colleagues, confers power to strike down any law she wishes for any reason she claims. They’re


confirming the justice and then finding out who she is. In a sense this is all so obvious it hardly bears stating. Of course the process complaints against Obamacare were disingenuous. If


the Trump era has proven anything, it’s that every single complaint about behavior norms or process that Republicans threw at Barack Obama was disingenuous. He’s rushing bills into law too


quickly! He’s arrogant! He’s using executive power! Cozying up with dictators! Disparaging American exceptionalism! Crony capitalism! Using a personal email address! Etc., etc. If Democrats


win control of government, Republicans will be back to complaining about process again. In particular, they will demand everything be done slowly and deliberately, and there will not be a


process slow and deliberate enough to satisfy them. But if the confirmation of the as-yet-unnamed third Trump Supreme Court justice demonstrates anything at all, it’s how utterly


disingenuous those claims about rushing through big changes without debate or bipartisan support really are.


Trending News

Chennai man smashes 20 cars after quarrel with wife, details here

In a recent series of incidents, a Chennai man, Boobalan, damaged 20 cars in a fit of rage following a quarrel with his ...

Profit to beat estimates - Los Angeles Times

Hewlett-Packard Co. surprised Wall Street by saying its earnings would be slightly above analysts’ expectations, going a...

Differential scanning calorimetry and stress relaxation of partially saponificated poly(vinyl alcohol)-dimethyl sulfoxide-water system

ABSTRACT In order to clarify the relation between the structure and properties of poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) gel, differe...

Freelance-Friendly Cities - GOOD

These are some of the most helpful suggestions for navigating life: "BE NICE TO EVERYBODY YOU MEET ON THE WAY UP TH...

Aarp is committed to a better 2024

In 2024, about 12,000 Americans a day will turn 65 as those born in the peak years of the baby boom continue to hit that...

Latests News

Senate republicans approve trump court nominee sight unseen

Photo: Sarah Silbiger/Getty Images Last night, less than three days after Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s sudden death, a gleeful ...

Mrs a dabrowska v coba automative (uk) ltd: 2601691/2020

MRS A DABROWSKA V COBA AUTOMATIVE (UK) LTD: 2601691/2020 Employment Tribunal decision. Read the full decision in Mrs A D...

Ysr family rift: vijayamma bats for sharmila, says jagan proposed property division

YSR Congress Party president YS Jagan Mohan Reddy’s mother YS Vijayamma on Tuesday, October 29 came out in support of he...

Fessenheim reactor to shut in 2016

PRESIDENT HOLLANDE ALSO TELLS ENVIRONMENTAL CONFERENCE THAT SHALE GAS EXPLORATION PERMITS ARE BEING REFUSED FRANCE'...

Congress mp sanjay nirupam threatens agitation if mumbai power tariff not cut

"If they take this decision, we will rethink about the morcha on January 13, or else the morcha will proceed to Rel...

Top