Investigating a correlation between poor oral health in the hospitalised geriatric population and an increased risk of mortality: what can we do?

ABSTRACT OBJECTIVE To review existing literature on oral health status (OHS) and its correlation with an increased mortality risk within the hospitalised geriatric population, to determine

suitable guidance and protocols. METHODOLOGY A search using several databases was undertaken for available publications. Medical subject headings (MeSH) search terms, Boolean operators and

truncators were applied. Exclusion and inclusion criteria were utilised to screen the 303 results, and five papers were critically appraised. RESULTS Two papers assessed oral health (OH)

interventions and their relationship with mortality outcomes; the remaining three were observational only. The three observational studies assessed OH using various validated tools and

indices against hospital records or phone call follow-ups for mortality outcome comparisons. Except for the systematic review, all studies found a correlation between OH and an increased

mortality risk. CONCLUSION Evidence for mortality outcomes among hospitalised geriatrics with an OH assessment for comparisons is limited. A correlation can be made with caution, but the

current evidence cannot determine a causal relationship, highlighting the need for advanced interventional multi-centred studies. You have full access to this article via your institution.

Download PDF AMELIA DAVIDGE is a third year student at the University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI). This article is a condensed version of the research she conducted as part of her

course. INTRODUCTION The percentage of the elderly population in the UK is increasing; 11 million people are aged 65 and over, accounting for 19% of the total population.1 The average life

expectancy is now 79.0 years for males and 82.9 years for females.2 Although, in the UK, the number of years an individual can expect to have good health without a disabling illness is 62.0

years for males and 60.7 years for females.3 Advancing age is associated with many comorbidities making the geriatric population more likely to suffer from health conditions and more likely

to require hospital admission; two-thirds of all hospital admissions are by people aged 65 years and over.4 Elderly patients are also at an increased risk of oral diseases such as dental

caries (DC) and periodontal disease (PD) as dental trends demonstrate the elderly retain a fuller natural dentition for longer, with restorations and prosthetics.5 Dentition retention poses

an increased risk of poor general health as there is a breadth of evidence proving the directional relationship between OH and systemic diseases such as cardiovascular disease (CD) and

diabetes by Kane,6 and rheumatoid arthritis by Detert _et al_.7 Therefore, complications arising from OH neglect pose an increased risk of mortality due to dental plaque bacteria aggravating

existing chronic disease.8,9 For this literature review, increased mortality risk can be defined as a death occurring, a decline in general health or poorer prognostic outcomes. Poor OH

causing increased mortality risk is identified from a causal link between PD and respiratory disease, including exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)10 and aspiration

pneumonia.11 Accordingly, the Department of Health12 advised mouth hygiene as a benchmark in the NHS Essence of Care best practice guidance, and The World Health Organisation13 (WHO) stated,

'OH as an essential determinant of quality of life, overall health, and happiness'. Despite this, policies for preventative oral care (OC) measures in hospitals are found

wanting,14 and government-funded oral health programmes no longer extend to hospitals.15,16 During hospitalisation, the patient is often removed from a setting where a carer delivers OC if

the patient lacks competency in self-care or if they are independent, their routine for self-care becomes disrupted, resulting in a decline in OHS for the patient.17 Hospital admission alone

poses the risk of rendering a patient reliant on support for OC due to the increased risk of delirium in over 65s in the acute medical setting.18 Nurses and healthcare assistants are

immeasurable in a patient's general health. However, the current nursing curriculum lacks sufficient education on OC for complex restored dentition and prostheses.19,20 Additionally,

healthcare assistants (HCA) receive no training in OC during their certification, despite being the primary providers of mouth care for in-patients within hospitals.14 Without training,

nurses and HCAs cannot deliver proper oral care. Furthermore, most hospital trusts do not have established referral pathways for dental services, and failure to provide dental services for

in-patients can lead to longer hospital admissions and increased mortality risk.21 > A personal driver for this review is witnessing an unsatisfactory > level of OC delivered to my 

grandmother while in hospital. Education > and exercise of oral and denture care appeared to be a low priority. Part of a dental therapist's (DT) role is the education on oral and

overall health; this is mostly within the general dental setting or public dental services (PDS), but they can provide treatment in the community (NHS). In addition, a DT's role

concerning geriatric dental care can include domiciliary visits to care homes for dental treatment and care staff education. However, a study by Monaghan and Morgan22 expressed that DTs are

underutilised within this setting. Therefore, I believe there is a need to fully utilise a DT's scope of practice within PDS, with their remit extending to OC and education within the

hospital setting. A personal driver for this review is witnessing an unsatisfactory level of OC delivered to my grandmother while in hospital. Education and exercise of oral and denture care

appeared to be a low priority. During admission, her COPD rapidly accelerated to end-stage, which was cited as the cause of death. I have often thought about the role OH played in her

passing. This literature review aims to investigate current evidence relating to the role of poor OH in mortality risk for hospitalised geriatric (>65 aged) patients. Identifying needs in

care delivery is one of the first steps to implementing changes and removing disparities in OH among the elderly. Furthermore, investigating a correlation identifies a need for future

research to be conducted to formulate or utilise preventative guidance for an improved prognostic outcome. METHODOLOGY A provisional search was conducted in September 2022, using the

advanced search option in Google Scholar with the following key terms: geriatric, elderly, oral health, DMFT, mortality and death. This generated 238 results published between 2012-2022.

Following the provisional search, an improved strategy was implemented for a focused and more comprehensive search. Several databases were utilised: PubMed, UHI Multisearch and EBSCO. For a

more refined search in line with the focused PICO question, the key terms were expanded from the provisional search with Boolean logic, MeSH terms and truncators applied. The search terms

were used within [title] and [abstract], which yielded 515 publications. Duplicates and results where access to the full text was unavailable were removed, and 303 publications were screened

resulting in the exclusion of 296 publications, leaving six papers remaining for the critical appraisal process.Before the critical appraisal, it was noted that the lead author of two

papers had used the same cohort of participants within the separate studies. In addition, an intervention used in the non-randomised control trial was not declared within the cohort paper.

Posing a high risk of concurrent intervention bias, it was decided to keep only the publication containing the intervention.A total of five papers were critically appraised using the

Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) checklists23 and the _BMJ_ cross-sectional analysis appraisal tool.24 This included two cohort studies, one cross-sectional, one non-randomised

control trial and one systematic review. RESULTS Amongst the results, a range of study methodologies was used, measuring different outcomes and exposures with a large sample of diagnostic

and OH indices utilised; therefore, a direct 1-1 comparison of the results cannot be made. All three observational papers displayed a link between poor OH and an increased risk of mortality,

Maeda and Mori,25 Noetzel _et al._26 and Bartoli _et al_.27 The non-randomised control trial by Shiraishi _et al._28 showed that OH interventions by a dental hygienist (DH) were associated

with lower in-hospital mortality. These results were echoed in the systematic review by Sjögren _et al._,29 where it was found that the mortality risk from hospital-acquired pneumonia (HAP)

improved with dental personnel OC interventions but did not improve when nursing personnel provided OC. Maeda and Mori25 reported that poor OH in older patients at the time of

hospitalisation was associated with an increased risk of in-hospital mortality. Eighteen percent of oral health assessment tool (OHAT) >3 group patients died compared to 6.3% of OHAT 1-2

and 5.2% of OHAT 0. Following post-hoc Bonferroni correction (_P _= 0.001) was observed for all three OHAT groups. Noetzel _et al._26 found that poorer OH and the multidimensional prognostic

index (MPI) were independently associated. Fifty percent of MPI 3 patients had died at the six-month follow-up, 23% of MPI 2 and 12.5% of MPI 1.However, the brief oral health status

examination (BOHSE), geriatric oral health assessment index (GOHAI) and decayed, missing, filled teeth index (DMFT) had no significant association with direct mortality; however, MPI is used

as a mortality risk predictor. Bartoli _et al._27 demonstrated that PD was an independent one-year mortality predictor; 96.7% of patients who died within one year had PD. Bartoli _et al._27

also found that plaque indices (PI) were an indicator of mortality in the MPI model but not in the model of comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA) comprising all variables; however, it

was recognised that hospitalisation may have impacted PI due to interference with normal OH regime. Shiraishi _et al._28 stated in their findings that DH care was independently associated

with lower in-hospital mortality after adjusting for covariates, evidenced by a 2% mortality rate with DH care vs 11% without DH care. Meta-analysis of five RCTs in the systematic review by

Sjögren _et al._29 found that OC interventions provided by professional dental personnel such as dentists, dental hygienists or other dental personnel reduced the HAP mortality risk with a

95% confidence interval. However, OC interventions provided by nursing personnel resulted in only a slight statistical difference in the mortality risks of HAP compared to usual oral care, a

mortality range of 1.7% to 28.1% in the intervention group compared to 1.6% to 20.0% in the control group, with a moderate certainty of the evidence. DISCUSSION This literature review

investigated a correlation between poor OH in the hospitalised geriatric population and increased mortality risk. The review has highlighted the need for further research. Despite the

breadth of evidence concerning OHS, general health and mortality outcomes, there is a lack of evidence specifically about geriatrics in a hospital setting. The geriatric patient demographic

is likely to have multiple confounding factors, making the results of previous studies, where participants are not specific to this focused demographic, less transferrable. All five studies

measure death as either the primary or secondary outcome; this measurement is objective and absolute, which aids in reducing the risk of detection and performance bias. Three of the five

studies were observational studies. A clear theme throughout the literature was that poor OH was positively and independently associated with a higher mortality outcome or risk. However,

despite this evidence, hospital OH policies lack clear guidance for healthcare staff.14 There were many limitations to this literature review; the word count is limited to 3,520, with a

restricted time frame; therefore, critical appraisal of the evidence included was condensed. Secondly, the available research was a heterogenous mixture, making it difficult to perform

direct 1-1 comparisons, adding to limitations in directly answering the PICO question. Finally, the lack of RCTs within the literature can be explained by ethical restrictions within that

study type when measuring mortality as an outcome. CONCLUSIONS The present literature suggests a correlation between poor OHS and mortality risk may exist within the hospitalised geriatric

patient. However, this must be engaged with caution as much of the evidence is only observational, which limits identifying a causal relationship. To conclude, the question has not fully

been answered; without establishing a causal relationship by manipulation of the variables, determining recommendations for practice in 'what can we do scenarios' is limited. > 

It is anticipated that studies will continue to raise recognition of > the importance of OH within geriatric patient care, such as daily > toothbrushing and manual cleaning of dentures

 aiming to reduce the > risk of oral diseases. RECOMMENDATIONS Further research is warranted, and it would be beneficial if future observational studies were multi-centred and

interventional, where ethical restrictions allow. A standardised methodological process should be conducted so that a direct 1-1 comparison can be made. The results can then be pooled

together for meta-analysis. Acute trusts can then utilise that research and formulate evidence-based guidelines for in-hospital oral healthcare services to eliminate inequalities in

geriatric oral healthcare for an improved prognosis. In the interim, it is anticipated that studies such as the ones within this literature review will continue to raise recognition of the

importance of OH within geriatric patient care, such as daily toothbrushing and manual cleaning of dentures aiming to reduce the risk of oral diseases. REFERENCES * Centre for Ageing Better.

_Summary. The State of Ageing 2022_. Available at: (accessed 14 October 2022). * Office for National Statistics. _Health state life expectancies, UK: 2018 to 2020_. Available at: (accessed

18 October 2022). * Office for National Statistics. _National life tables - life expectancy in the UK: 2018 to 2020_. Available at:

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/lifeexpectancies/bulletins/nationallifetablesunitedkingdom/2018to2020 (accessed 18 October 2022). * Nuffield

Department of Population Health. _Hospital or 'hospital at home' - what's best for older people? _Available at:

https://www.ndph.ox.ac.uk/longer-reads/hospital-or-2018hospital-at-home2019-2013-what2019s-best-for-older-people (accessed 15 October 2022). * Watt R, Steele J, Treasure E, White D A, Pitts

N B, Murray J J. Adult Dental Health Survey 2009: implications of findings for clinical practice and oral health policy. _Br Dent J _2013; 214: 71-75. * Kane S F. The effects of oral health

on systemic health. _Gen Dent _2017; 65: 30-34. * Detert J, Pischon N, Burmester G R, Buttgereit F. The association between rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease. _Arthritis Res Ther

_2010; doi: doi: 10.1186/ar3106. * Paganini-Hill A, White S C, Atchison K A. Dental health behaviors, dentition, and mortality in the elderly: the leisure world cohort study'. _J Aging

Res _2011; doi: 10.4061/2011/156061. * Klotz A L, Hassel A J, Schröder J, Rammelsberg P, Zenthöfer A. Is compromised oral health associated with a greater risk of mortality among nursing

home residents? A controlled clinical study. _Aging Clin Exp Res _2018; 30: 581-588. * Cullinan M P, Seymour G J. Periodontal disease and systemic illness: will the evidence ever be enough?

_Periodontol 2000_; 2013; 62: 271-286. * Müller F. Oral hygiene reduces the mortality from aspiration pneumonia in frail elders. _J Dent Res_ 2015; 94: 14S-16S. * Department of Health.

_Essence of Care 2010. Benchmarks for Personal Hygiene._ Norwich: The Stationery Office, 2010. Available at: (accessed 28 October 2022). * World Health Organization. _Oral health_. Available

at: (accessed 25 October 2022). * Binks C, Doshi M, Mann J. Standardising the delivery of oral health care practice in hospitals. _Nursing Times _2017; 113: 18-21. * NICE. _Oral health in

care homes and hospitals NICE quality standard. Draft for consultation_. 2017. Available at: (accessed April 2023). * Mouth Care Matters. _The Mouth Care Matters programme has now closed_.

14 February 2020. Available at: https://mouthcarematters.hee.nhs.uk/2020/02/14/the-mouth-care-matters-programme-has-now-closed/index.html (accessed 18 October 2022). * Terezakis E, Needleman

I, Kumar N, Moles D, Agudo E. The impact of hospitalization on oral health: a systematic review. _J Clin Periodontol_ 2011; 38: 628-636. * Wand A P, Thoo W, Ting V, Baker J, Sciuriaga H,

Hunt G E. Identification and rates of delirium in elderly medical in-patients from diverse language groups. _Geriatr Nurs _2013;34: 355-360. * Salamone K, Yavoub E, Mahoney A, Edward K. Oral

care of hospitalised older patients in the acute medical setting. _Nurs Res Pract_ 2013; doi: 10.1155/2013/827670. * Doshi M, Mann J, Quentin L, Morton-Holtham L, Eaton K A. Mouth care

training and practice: a survey of nursing staff working in National Health Service hospitals in England. _J Res Nurs _2021; 26: 574-590. * Hashem I, Gillway D, Doshi M. Dental care pathways

for adult in-patients in an acute hospital: a five-year service evaluation. _Br Dent J _2020; 228: 687-692. * Monaghan N P, Morgan M Z. What proportion of dental care in care homes could be

met by direct access to dental therapists or dental hygienists? _Br Dent J _2015; 219: 531-534. * CASP. _CASP Checklists_. Available at: https://casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/ (accessed

20 October 2022). * Downes M J, Brennan M L, Williams H C, Dean R S. Development of a critical appraisal tool to assess the quality of cross-sectional studies (AXIS). _BMJ Open_ 2016; doi:

10.1136/bmjopen-2016-011458. * Maeda K, Mori N. Poor oral health and mortality in geriatric patients admitted to an acute hospital: an observational study. _BMC Geriatr _2020; doi:

10.1186/s12877-020-1429-z. * Noetzel N, Meyer A M, Siri G _et al_. The impact of oral health on prognosis of older multimorbid in-patients: the 6-month follow up MPI oral health study

(MPIOH). _Eur Geriatr Med _2021; 12: 263-273. * Bartoli G, Omiciulo C, Fiorenzato F _et al_. Oral health status as predictor of 1-year mortality after discharge from an acute geriatric unit.

_Eur Geriatr Med _2019; 10: 889-897. * Shiraishi A, Yoshimura Y, Wakabayashi H, Tsuji Y, Yamaga M, Koga H. Hospital dental hygienist intervention improves activities of daily living, home

discharge and mortality in post-acute rehabilitation. _Geriatr Gerontol Int _2019; 19: 189-196. * Sjögren P, Wårdh I, Zimmerman M, Almståhl A, Wikström M. Oral care and mortality in older

adults with pneumonia in hospitals or nursing homes: systematic review and meta-analysis. _J Am Geriatr Soc _2016; 64: 2109-2115. Download references AUTHOR INFORMATION AUTHORS AND

AFFILIATIONS * University of the Highlands and Islands, Scotland, UK Amelia Davidge Authors * Amelia Davidge View author publications You can also search for this author inPubMed Google

Scholar RIGHTS AND PERMISSIONS Reprints and permissions ABOUT THIS ARTICLE CITE THIS ARTICLE Davidge, A. Investigating a correlation between poor oral health in the hospitalised geriatric

population and an increased risk of mortality: what can we do?. _BDJ Team_ 10, 8–11 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41407-023-1815-4 Download citation * Published: 21 April 2023 * Issue

Date: 21 April 2023 * DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41407-023-1815-4 SHARE THIS ARTICLE Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content: Get shareable link Sorry,

a shareable link is not currently available for this article. Copy to clipboard Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative