Noncitizens voting in LAUSD elections? Bad idea

Latimes

Noncitizens voting in LAUSD elections? Bad idea"


Play all audios:

Loading...

In what’s becoming a mini-trend of sorts, the Los Angeles Unified School District is considering the question of whether to let noncitizens with children in the schools vote in school board


elections. A resolution up for debate Nov. 5 would establish a working committee to examine the issues around bringing such a proposal before voters.


The board could save itself time and trouble by doing the right thing and killing the resolution. Though the district should encourage the involvement of parents no matter what their


immigration status is, the privilege of voting is one that rightly belongs to citizens.


L.A. Unified is following in the footsteps of San Francisco, which started allowing noncitizen parents of its students to vote in 2018. It didn’t work as planned; fewer than 50 people


registered.


But the practicalities aren’t what matter here. We’ve all heard about the checks and balances inherent in a democratic way of government. The ultimate check on government power – exercised


by too few people – is the one exerted by the voters who can throw the rascals out if they choose. That oversight rightly belongs to those who are tied to the government in a formal and


binding way by citizenship.


Supporters of expanding the vote correctly point out that parents have a special stake in schools, regardless of their official status. (This resolution would explore voting privileges for


noncitizen grandparents as well.) But there are many ways for noncitizens to participate in their children’s schooling. They can join and lead the PTA and other parent organizations, serve


on advisory committees and sign up with community advocacy groups.


And noncitizens have a big interest in many other aspects of government than schools. The services provided and regulations enacted around healthcare, the environment, transportation and


public safety all have direct impacts on the people living here, citizens and otherwise.


In fact, the philosophy behind the L.A. Unified resolution represents a troubling way of viewing voter participation. Voting rights shouldn’t be extended based on who is most directly


affected by a particular issue. Voting on health coverage isn’t extended to sick noncitizens; voting on gas taxes isn’t extended to noncitizens with cars. We all have a stake together in how


government policy affects people, and ways of influencing that policy to the good. But noncitizens have joined the nation on the understanding that voting is not one of the privileges


extended to them; that comes with taking an oath of allegiance when immigrants are naturalized.


The right way to extend the vote to noncitizens is to encourage those here legally to work toward citizenship and to provide a path to citizenship for the undocumented. That would strengthen


the state and the nation with a more robust roster of citizen voters.


Trending News

Federal Judge to Hear California’s Case Against Trump’s Deployment of Troops to Los Angeles

A federal judge will hold a hearing on Thursday over California’s request to block the Trump Administration from using t...

Why Austria Has Some of the Most Relaxed Gun Ownership Laws in Europe

A school shooting in Graz, Austria left at least nine people dead and 12 injured Tuesday, prompting renewed attention to...

What the National Guard Crackdown in LA Made Us See

I was wondering at what point the nation that elected President Donald Trump twice would reach a collective breaking poi...

Remembering Darcelle: Sweet, cheeky fun • Oregon ArtsWatch

That’s No Lady, Don Horn’s encore staging of his twinkling tribute to Portland’s legendary drag queen Darcelle/Walter Co...

Searching for Devils at CECOT | TIME

To grasp why El Salvador built the Terrorism Confinement Center—the prison known as CECOT—you need to know about the kil...

Latests News

Noncitizens voting in LAUSD elections? Bad idea

In what’s becoming a mini-trend of sorts, the Los Angeles Unified School District is considering the question of whether...

Malaysia-China Relations Since MH370

The disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 has not had a long-lasting impact on Malaysia-China relations.The Asia...

Kenya tourist lodge shuts after land invasions and wildlife killings

NAIROBI, June 5 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - A lodge owned by a murdered British rancher in Kenya's northern Laikipia ...

Pax Sinica | Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

Russia EurasiaresearchpolitikaaboutexpertsmoreeventsCarnegie Politika PodcastTopics & RegionsTopicssee all topicsSecurit...

Impact of The Global Financial Crisis: Predictions Gone Wrong

One of the most striking aspects of the global financial crisis has been how often the facts have contradicted what, acc...

Top