Lean state finances put squeeze on policy groups

Edweek

Lean state finances put squeeze on policy groups"


Play all audios:

Loading...

The awful budget situations in many states are also taking a toll on most of the leading national organizations that help states shape education policies. The Education Commission of the


States may be the hardest hit so far. A compact of governors, legislatures, and state education officials best known for its information clearinghouse, the Denver-based ECS has been forced


to cut its staff and rework its budget in recent months. “We’ve cut every conceivable thing we could find in our budget that was not absolutely required,” ECS President Ted Sanders said in


an interview. Part of the problem stems from the budget shortfalls in a majority of states that are making it hard for some to pay dues, register for conferences, and hire the services of


such groups. The Council of Chief State School Officers, the National Conference of State Legislatures, and the National Association of State Boards of Education all report that states are


being careful with their spending—and that the caution is rippling through the policy groups. “We’re in a big hole right now,” said David Griffith, the spokesman for the group of state


education boards, known as NASBE, in Alexandria, Va. His group and the other nonprofit organizations are limiting their own travel budgets and delaying new hires to deal with fallout from


state budget shortfalls. At the ECS, Mr. Sanders said he has cut five positions on the staff, including a vice president’s post, resulting in four layoffs. The fifth position was already


open. He also plans to furlough employees assigned to specific projects when funding for the projects dries up, which has led to at least one other resignation. The organization now has 69


permanent employees. State dues are running $275,000 short at the ECS this year, with California and Wisconsin delaying their full payments because of budget constraints, Mr. Sanders said.


He added that overall ECS revenue is up 16 percent from last year, thanks to new grants from private foundations and corporate partners. The group, which has an annual budget of about $13


million, is saving almost $350,000 in cuts from travel, training, technology, and publications costs. GROUPS STRAPPED At the Council of Chief State School Officers, the governing board


recently decided not to raise state dues for this year, fearing the CCSSO might lose member states. Dues for membership in the state-policy groups range from about $13,000 for the smaller


states and organizations to $130,000 for the larger states’ ECS dues. Scott Montgomery, the chief of staff for the Washington-based CCSSO, said his organization is trying to focus on what


its members want the most: help with implementing the federal “No Child Left Behind” Act of 2001. “We’ve actually made some contingencies in our own budget in case a certain percentage of


states can’t pay their dues,” Mr. Montgomery said. “Who knows what the future will bring? Everybody’s in a crisis.” At NASBE, Mr. Griffith said attendance was solid at the group’s recent


Washington conference for state board members on the new federal law. But he pointed out: “Had this been a better time, I think the attendance would have been much higher.” The state


legislatures’ group in Denver also is watching its pennies, said NCSL spokesman Gene Rose. “We do have some positions that are being left open, and we’re having to watch our expenses,” he


said. The Education Leaders Council in Washington, founded as a conservative group for state-level education leaders, depends on federal money for special projects and on individual,


inexpensive dues. Spokeswoman Kimberly Tulp said those factors have kept the small organization from feeling much effects from state budget crises. Leaders of the state- policy organizations


agree that states need their help more than ever, which bodes well for the groups’ long-term finances. TREADING CAREFULLY Until state revenues return to normal, though, they expect to make


some difficult decisions in the times to come. “I think it’s going to be tougher, not easier, in the days ahead,” said Mr. Sanders of the ECS. “And I worry a little bit personally that the


states’ financial dilemma is going to be deeper and last longer than what we’ve experienced at least in my 40 years working with state policy.” The ECS apparently didn’t help its case when


it released a report recently that showed how some states were moving slowly to meet the requirements of the No Child Left Behind law. Observers can look at colorful charts on the ECS Web


site to see which states have policies in place that meet new federal rules on teacher quality, test-score analysis, and more. The exposure of possible shortcomings in those state policies


created tension between the ECS and leaders in some member states. “I don’t think our initial experience with the survey was a very good one,” said Suellen K. Reed, the state superintendent


in Indiana. “They do some things that are very helpful,” she added, expressing her appreciation for the work of the ECS. But releasing the report as state officials are sorting through the


new federal requirements while dealing with budget crises of their own, however, “was not helpful,” she said. Mr. Sanders acknowledged criticism over the report, but the former deputy U.S.


education secretary and state superintendent in Ohio and Illinois said the fallout hadn’t hurt his group’s finances. “We’ve got a couple of the chief state schools officers who are not


particularly enamored with the analytical work we’ve done on ‘No Child Left Behind,’” he said. “But for the most part, the reaction we’ve had from the states relative to that analysis has


been far more positive than negative.” Iowa’s state education director, Ted Stilwell, said he spoke with Mr. Sanders about the report. But Mr. Stilwell blamed the dust-up on the political


situation state leaders and policy groups face right now. “That’s just more symptomatic of the pressures on anybody,” he said. “Everybody’s trying to sort out what their role is. I’m not


surprised that there are some bumps in the road.”


Trending News

We can grow scotland’s economy and make our nation thrive — scottish national party

Looking around this room today, I see many other ambitious Scottish businesses represented. Like me, I know you will be ...

5 surprises from our interview with Huawei CEO Ren Zhengfei

As billionaires go, Ren Zhengfei is an enigma. He built his high-tech empire, but has kept a very low profile. CTV Natio...

Ucla library announces winter 2021 public programs

In January, February and early March, the UCLA Library will present dozens of virtual events — from research and data sc...

The world is full of innovation more important than ad algorithms

THE WORLD IS FULL OF INNOVATION MORE IMPORTANT THAN AD ALGORITHMS To find them, you just need to look beyond Silicon Val...

Andheri: four booked for fleeing quarantine centre

Four people, including a woman, who arrived from Dubai have been booked by the Andheri police for allegedly fleeing the ...

Latests News

Lean state finances put squeeze on policy groups

The awful budget situations in many states are also taking a toll on most of the leading national organizations that hel...

Winners and losers at the 2025 baftas | thearticle

The main problem with the BAFTAs, which took place this week, is that, too often, they give too many awards to mediocre ...

Mikel arteta hopes pierre-emerick aubameyang keeps hitting landmarks for arsenal

Mikel Arteta is hopeful captain Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang can score another 100 goals for Arsenal after he reached his P...

Film reviews: inferno, storks and american honey

At least, that is what they used to do. Now the storks deliver consumer goods like mobile phones (perhaps having decided...

Some might prefer the scent of roses...

Some might prefer the scent of roses . . . : The February calendar for the Knolls, an upscale apartment complex in Thous...

Top