Administration: student-grading flap not a federal case

Edweek

Administration: student-grading flap not a federal case"


Play all audios:

Loading...

The Bush administration has urged the U.S. Supreme Court not to grant review of an Oklahoma case that centers on whether the practice of having students grade each other’s classwork violates


federal law. The solicitor general’s office says in a legal brief recently filed with the justices that a federal appeals court was wrong to strike down the grading practice as a violation


of the Family Education Rights and Privacy Act, or FERPA. But rather than review and overturn the ruling, the court should allow the Department of Education to issue formal regulations


clarifying that FERPA does not prohibit student grading and similar classroom practices, the brief argues. “The department has determined that it will issue regulations or other formal


guidance setting forth a more detailed analysis of the meaning of ‘education records’ under FERPA and the application of that term and of FERPA not only to the particular practice at issue


in this case, but also to a variety of other practices,” said the solicitor general’s brief filed in _Owasso Independent School District_ v. _Falvo_ (Case No. 00- 1073). FERPA, also known as


the Buckley Amendment, prohibits educational institutions from releasing students’ school records without parental consent. The question in the Oklahoma case is whether allowing students to


grade one another’s work constitutes the release of an educational record. In the 1997- 98 school year, an Owasso, Okla., parent, Kristja J. Falvo, complained to the school district about


the assignment of students to grade each other’s work and call out the grades in class. She said the practices embarrassed her three school-age children, who were in grades 5-7 at the time.


When the district refused her request to stop the practices, Ms. Falvo filed a lawsuit claiming they violated both FERPA and her 14th Amendment right to privacy. Last July, a three-judge


panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, in Denver, ruled unanimously that Ms. Falvo had no valid 14th Amendment claim, but that the grading practices violated FERPA. The


appellate panel rejected the Education Department’s view, contained in a 1993 policy letter, that students’ grading of each other’s work was not yet an education record maintained by the


school district. The 6,700-student Owasso district sought a rehearing before the full 10th Circuit court last fall. The request was denied by a 6-4 vote, which leaves the panel’s opinion as


the law in that circuit, which covers Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah, and Wyoming. CLASSROOM CONCERNS Meanwhile, the ruling has caused concern for school districts and


teachers, who fear that it could mean several common classroom practices might be prohibited under FERPA. The National Education Association asked the Education Department to issue


regulations clarifying the meaning of the law. Jim Bradshaw, a department spokesman, said last week that officials were “considering the best means of clarifying our position.” Under Supreme


Court rulings, formal regulations would likely be accorded more deference by the federal courts than the 1993 policy letter. But such regulations might not free schools in the six states


covered by the 10th Circuit from that court’s ruling against student grading. “Until the Supreme Court addresses the issue, I think the rule announced in _Falvo_ will be in force in the 10th


Circuit regardless of any regulations from the Education Department,” said Jerry A. Richardson, a lawyer for the Owasso district. The district appealed the 10th Circuit court’s ruling to


the high court, which in March asked the Bush administration for its views on the case.


Trending News

11 reasons why we should reconnect with our old friends - scoopwhoop

They say that nothing is permanent in today’s world. But they’re wrong. Things come and go, you witness ups and downs, r...

Killings in gaza, new embassy in jerusalem, and peace as distant as ever (published 2018)

JERUSALEM — Across the Gaza Strip on Monday morning, loudspeakers on minarets urged Palestinians to rush the fence borde...

Bbl 9: shane watson previews sydney sixers

Tweet Share Copy URL Series Preview 84 videos Champions of the inaugural edition of BBL, Sydney Sixers are also the only...

Victoria election: freedom movement parties fail to make an impact

After years of predicting that the Victorian election would be the culmination of a people’s revolution to wrest control...

Alex jones finally reveals baby son's super cute name

However, that was until today, when The One Show favourite took to her Instagram page to reveal what her and her husband...

Latests News

Administration: student-grading flap not a federal case

The Bush administration has urged the U.S. Supreme Court not to grant review of an Oklahoma case that centers on whether...

'i was at routine appointment when doctor found something terrifying on my back'

KAREN DICKINSON, 57, WAS AT AN APPOINTMENT ABOUT HER KNEE WHEN THE OSTEOPATH NOTICED A MOLE ON HER LOWER BACK WHICH TEST...

The leading man : brett butler is the player giants are counting on to get things started

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. — They played “Tara’s Theme” from “Gone With the Wind” each time Brett Butler went to the plate with t...

Javascript support required...

//

* Vivre loin de sa famille * La simplicité volontaire * J'ai l'impression que mes rondeurs n'attire pas l...

Top