Crying Wolf About the School-Economy Connection (Opinion)

Edweek

Crying Wolf About the School-Economy Connection (Opinion)"


Play all audios:

Loading...

Share article Remove Save to favorites Save to favorites Print Email Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Copy URL Walt Gardner Walt Gardner taught for 28 years in the Los Angeles Unified School


District and was a lecturer in the UCLA Graduate School of Education.


At the risk of sounding like a Pollyanna, I have to take issue with the latest alarmist depiction of public education in this country. On Dec. 30, the New York Times published a news story


about the Program for International Student Achievement. The article said that the rankings augured ill for America’s competitiveness in the new global economy (“Shanghai Schools’ Approach


Pushes Students to Top of Tests”). Or as Arne Duncan said: the PISA rankings are a “wake-up call.”


The trouble with this assessment is that it is hardly new. Taxpayers were exposed to similar hyperbole before in, of all places, Life magazine. The March 24, 1958 cover story showed


side-by-side photos of two high school juniors. One was a dour Alexei Kutzkov in Moscow and the other was a beaming Stephen Lapekas in Chicago. Their contrasting faces were used as a


springboard to lure readers into the full feature. The Russian was shown involved in complicated physics experiments and reading aloud from Sister Carrie , while the American was shown


rehearsing for the school play and walking his girlfriend home after school. The International Herald Tribune published my op-ed about this issue on Jan. 14, 2008 (“The ‘crisis’ of U.S.


education”).


As simplistic as the artifice seems, the Life feature achieved its objective of creating widespread anxiety. This angst was subsequently compounded by the publication of A Nation at Risk in


1983. Its most famous line is familiar: “If an unfriendly power had attempted to impose on America the mediocre educational performance that exists today, we might well have viewed it as an


act of war.”


The alleged proof were scores on tests of international competition. But as I pointed out in my op-ed, the thesis was discredited by subsequent events. Japan, whose students ranked high on


such tests, saw its economy tank in 1990. In contrast, the U.S. entered the longest period of economic prosperity in its history starting in 1991.


So I’ll ask the question again: If public schools are as wretched as critics contend, then why did the U.S. prosper? Conversely, if Japan’s schools were as exemplary as critics maintained at


the time, then why did the country’s economy implode?


The truth is that the economic health of the U.S. is far more the result of policies that schools have nothing to do with at all. Public schools run the range from excellent to execrable.


But none of them caused the Great Recession. It occurred because of laxity in enforcing regulations, fraudulent accounting practices and abandonment of prudent rules for mortgages.


In light of the evidence available, I wonder why so many taxpayers continue to believe what they are fed by those whose prior cries of doom have not come true?


The opinions expressed in Walt Gardner’s Reality Check are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its


publications.


Trending News

Pregnant Jana Kramer Reveals Her Baby Boy on the Way 'Truly Has Been a Savior' for Her Marriage

Pregnant Jana Kramer Reveals Her Baby Boy on the Way 'Truly Has Been a Savior' for Her Marriage Jana Kramer reveals to P...

Local News in Brief : Police Task Force Hunts Robbery Gang

A Los Angeles police task force has been formed to hunt down a gang suspected of robbing a dozen armored car guards and ...

Realty network links with marketing firm

Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Service, Des Moines, Iowa, and the Greenman Group Inc., Hollywood, Fla., have annou...

Kerala’s TPR fluctuates as 7,283 new cases of COVID-19 reported on Friday

The test positivity rate or TPR of COVID-19 in Kerala has been fluctuating between 12 and 18 in the last four days. On F...

Panda poop: the missing link for cheap, renewable energy?

Pandas may hold the key to efficiently and cheaply turning plants into renewable energy — in their feces. This week, at ...

Latests News

Crying Wolf About the School-Economy Connection (Opinion)

Share article Remove Save to favorites Save to favorites Print Email Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Copy URL Walt Gardner Wal...

Covid-19 surge: canada to ban flights from india and pakistan

Ontario Premier Doug Ford, meanwhile, apologised Thursday for a failed attempt to close playgrounds and allow police to ...

Attention Required! | Cloudflare

Please enable cookies. Sorry, you have been blocked You are unable to access boldsky.com Why have I been blocked? This w...

Dalgety directors complete buyout

- 26 May 1998 https://www.fwi.co.uk More in News Dalgety directors complete buyout - 26 May 1998 >More in News 26 May 19...

Who Killed Arlene Hoffman? : People: The just-hired secretary to Orange County Supervisor Jim Silva was slain by an arrow at her home. Friends say she

There is no way to do justice to the memory of Arlene Hoffman, her childhood friends say, no way to express the loss of ...

Top