Massive embarrassment for CBI Director Ranjit Sinha 12 days before retirement

Twelve days before his retirement, CBI Director Ranjit Sinha today suffered a major blow when the Supreme Court removed him from the 2G scam case, saying the allegations against him of

protecting some accused appears to be "prima facie credible". The apex court, in an unprecedented order, handed over the case to the senior-most officer after Sinha in the 2G scam

investigating team. A bench headed by Chief Justice HL Dattu, however, refused to pass an elaborate order on the issue saying that it would "tarnish" the "image and reputation" of the

premier agency.

The fate of the top cop, who is due to retire on December 2, in the case became abundantly clear when the bench, also comprising justices MB Lokur and AK Sikri, before rising for the lunch

break, asked senior advocate Vikas Singh, appearing for Sinha, about various options. The court said it did not want to pass an elaborate order, because it would be against the interest and

image of the agency. "Prima facie the allegations made in the application(by NGO Centre for Public Interest Litigation) are credible and required to be accepted," the bench observed.

However, his counsel insisted that the allegations levelled against Sinha of scuttling the 2G probe were "untrue". The CBI chief's role was criticised by the apex court- appointed Special

Public Prosecutor Anand Grover and counsel appearing for CBI, K K Venugopal, also raised questions on Sinha naming a senior IPS officer as mole in the team. The apex court also recalled its

earlier order by which it directed the NGO to disclose the name of whistleblower who had provided documents and visitors diary of Sinha's residence.

At the outset, the Special Public Prosecutor raised serious questions on the conduct of the top cop and contended that the whole case against some of the accused would have been "demolished"

if Sinha's instructions had been followed in the trial. Grover said that stand taken by Sinha was "completely inconsistent" with the agency's stand and said he tried to interfere at the

last stage of the trial when the prosecution evidence was almost over.

He said that information that he gathered, after going through all file notings, is "shocking" and cannot be revealed in an open court. The independent prosecutor also raised questions on

the opinion of Law Ministry to allegedly favour some of the firms facing trial in 2G case. "It is a sad story how ministry works. An official deposed saying that it was done on the basis of

file notings of the Minister but the question is who was the person behind the Minister. Its shocking," he said.

At this stage of proceedings, the hearing took a new turn with advocate Prashant Bhushan alleging that CBI counsel in 2G case KK Venugopal was directed by Sinha not to argue in this case. 

The bench then queried who had given such direction. CBI joint Director Ashok Tiwari, who was present in the court room, said that Venugopal continues to be the CBI counsel in the apex court

and also tried to shield his chief in the present controversy.

The court took strong exception to Tiwari trying to defend his boss and also raised question on the presence of around nine senior officers of CBI inside the court room. "You are not agents

of the Director and you cannot be his mouthpiece. You do not need to take responsibility. How is your presence required here," the bench questioned.

"Why so many CBI officers are here. How come so many officers sitting in the court room. We do not require their presence. We are not hearing 2G investigation case. We are hearing an

application filed against the Director," it said. The bench asked the officers to leave the courtroom and "do their duty rather than observing court proceedings". The officers thereafter

left the courtroom. 

Venugopal then brought to court's notice media reports on Singh naming a DIG-rank officer Santosh Rastogi as a "mole" who supplied documents and guest list of Director's residence to

Bhushan. 

The CBI through Venugopal criticised Sinha's stand and urged the court to ask him to withdraw the statement. "Yesterday's statement was not right that the officer is a mole in the CBI. If

there is any evidence then it must be produced. The statement must be withdrawn as the officer needs protection," he said.

Bhushan also submitted that he never met the officer and somebody else had given him the documents and filed an affidavit in this regard which was taken on record.

The bench also raised objection that image of the officer cannot be allowed to be tarnished and said that it was wrong on the part of Sinha's counsel to name the officer while arguing the

case. Going by file notings on transfer of the officer, the bench said, "It seems that you want to clear the path as the officer was opposing some of your decisions".

The bench said the decision taken by the Director to transfer the officer amounts to "overreaching" the apex court order which had directed that no person in 2G probe team be removed without

its order. It said that "all is not well" and "some allegations against him (Sinha) appeared to be prima facie credible and asked Singh about the options available in the case as it did not

want to pass an elaborate order with reasons which would have the potential to tarnish the image and reputation of the premier institution.

Vikas Singh, however, preferred to continue with his arguments saying that statements made by SPP and others against the Director is patently false and baseless. He said that Director's

decision may not be the best but there was no malafide and dishonest intention behind the decision.

The bench, however, brushed aside the contention saying, "For every thing there is justification but the justification should appeal to us".

At the end of the four-hour long proceedings, the bench passed a brief order directing Sinha to keep himself away from the 2G case and "not to interfere in the investigation and trial of the

2G cases and recuse himself from them".

"To protect the faith in the institution and reputation of Director, CBI, we are not focusing on elaborate reasons and it is suffice to say information furnished by applicants prima facie

appears to be credible and therefore required to be accepted," the bench said. 

Kesari Chapter 2 OTT release: Akshay Kumar, R Madhavan, Ananya Panday's courtroom drama film to release on..., here's when and where you can watch

Arbaaz Khan, Sshura Khan to become parents, confirms actor: 'It's a new...'

Why is Axiom-4 Mission significant for ISRO? How will it help India's manned- mission of Gaganyaan? Shubhansu Shukla will ...

Not Aishwarya Rai, Madhuri Dixit, Katrina Kaif, Salman Khan once broke strict no kiss policy for this actress, her name is..

This move by China in Africa is making US restless, top American military official claims Beijing is copying Washington's..., aim is to...

This Indian man who sold waste at 11, worked as mechanic, now owns 22 flats in Dubai's Burj Khalifa, his net worth is Rs...

BIG changes in UPI: Google Pay, PhonePe, Paytm users will not be able to check...., from...

This liquor manufacturer now owns Vijay Mallya's Kingfisher Villa in Goa, renamed it King's Mansion, originally priced at Rs…, bought at Rs…, his Bollywood connection is...

Panchayat season 4 trailer: Elections bring drama and chaos in Neena Gupta aka Manju Devi's Phulera, release date preponed

Ed Sheeran says 'no one makes movies like Bollywood, Tollywood films': 'I watch loads of...'

'Jaya and I decided that...': Abhishek Bachchan or Shweta Bachchan? Who will inherit Amitabh Bachchan's property, no mention of Aishwarya Rai, Aaradhya

DNA Verified: Is Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan seriously ill? Truth is...

Amid Sonam-Raja Raghuvanshi shocking case, another honeymoon couple from UP goes missing in Sikkim, know what happened

Meet actor, with over Rs 3000 crore net worth, business partners with Sunil Gavaskar, Tendulkar, Dhoni, his name is..., not Shah Rukh Khan, Amitabh Bachchan

Housefull 5: Soundarya Sharma reacts to criticism on 'sexist jokes' from Akshay Kumar's film: 'We are not endorsing nudity' | Exclusive

Meet superstar's wife, daughter of a millionaire, who never acted in films, is successful businesswoman with over Rs 300 crore net worth, her husband is..

This airline to shut down soon, will lay off 500 employees, affected staff will be offered..., is closing due to...

This actor played cupid in Asin and Rahul Sharma's love story, got them married; he is worth Rs 2500 crore

Meet man who worked as watchman after father's death, later followed his brother's footsteps, cracked CAT, now studying at this IIM college, he is from..., his name...

No ticket is needed to travel on this train, passengers have been travelling for free for 75 years, it runs from..., its schedule, station are, it's name is...

26 degrees in Japan, 23 in Italy, 21 is US, here's why AC's minimum temperature in India might not go below 20 degrees Celsius

Bollywood's renowned hairstylist died after Amitabh Bachchan's haircut, his son just had Rs 13 in his account, now charges Rs 1 lakh for single sitting, he is..

Meet 11-year-old YouTube star who is giving tough competition to MrBeast, has over 135 million subscribers, earns around..., is from...

Shilpa Shetty gets in verbal spat with tourist in Croatia? Viral video leaves the internet divided

This film, rejected by Sridevi, made Raveena Tandon a superstar, became second highest-grossing Indian film of 1994, earned 6 times its budget, movie was..

Navjot Singh Sidhu charges this whopping amount to return to The Great Indian Kapil Show 3

ChatGPT-maker OpenAI signs massive deal with Google amid fierce AI competition, it is...

COVID-19 in India Live updates: Active tally nears 7000-mark, 324 fresh cases, 3 deaths reported, check latest update here

Meet man who ditched family's iron and steel business, started his own company with Rs 5000 investment, now earns Rs 70 crore annually, he is...

Raja Raghuvanshi murder case: What was Sonam Raghuvanshi's alleged lover Raj Kushwaha's monthly salary? Report claims it is Rs...

Pakistan's close friend Turkey is battling big crisis, is on top of this list as it has one of world's highest...

Big update on Indian astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla's Axiom-4 mission, launch postponed as SpaceX detects...

This actress' mother abused her, she fell in love with 35-year-old married man at 15, attempted suicide; she is now...

Another big move by Anil Ambani, Reliance Infrastructure signs Rs 10000 crore deal with this company, will manufacture...

Meet man, who once worked as newspaper boy, grew up in orphanage, became IAS officer without clearing UPSC examination, he is..., he is from...

Meghalaya murder case: Sonam Raghuvanshi allegedly paid a large sum of Rs... to contract killers for husband Raja Raghuvanshi's murder, police say...

'We are shattered, cried...': Puja Banerjee, Kunal Verma lose their entire-life saving after a close friend cheats them

Vatsal Sheth, Ishita Dutta become parents to baby girl: 'Our family is now complete'

Delhi weather update: IMD issues orange alert as heat wave hits Delhi-NCR, maximum temperature to reach...

Protests intensify in Los Angeles after Donald Trump deploys hundreds of National Guard troops, here's what we know so far

Meet world’s youngest self-made female billionaire, a college dropout, who still drives old Honda, her net worth is Rs...; runs business of...

Rs 13 lakh a year needed': LinkedIn user breaks down cost of raising single child, says, ‘Indians need to have a salary of Rs...’

Meet woman who leads MS Dhoni's Rs 800 crore empire, very close to Sakshi Dhoni, not her sister, friend, she is...

Meet actress who starred opposite Shah Rukh Khan, later quit films, married to businessman, now back into spotlight with Rs 400 crore...

WTC 2025 Final: Best picks of possible XI for Australia vs South Africa's match at Lord's

Meet woman, IIM graduate, who used to earn Rs 200 crore, top US company wanted to hire her, her net worth is Rs...

Meet man, son of acclaimed Indian film director, contesting election to become New York City's first-ever Muslim mayor

Who is Khaby Lame? World's most-followed TikToker now forced to leave US, reason is...

Enrique Iglesias to perform in India after 13 years, check date, venue, ticket cost; here's everything you need to know about his concert

Woman in Karnataka files case alleging neighbour stole her cat, High Court says...

Pakistani man brutally stabs wife to death in Navi Mumbai flat, what he does next will shock you

US President Donald Trump's BIG move, imposes ban on THESE countries for..., know details

DNA TV Show: What's happening in Los Angeles as Donald Trump deployed 2000 National Guard troops

Thug Life box office collection day 6: Kamal Haasan film set to become one of the biggest flops, fails to earn even Rs 2 crore

Big action against IAS Dhiman Chakma, days after being caught accepting Rs 10 lakh bribe: 'He shall not...'

Pakistan's Mohammad Rizwan, Shaheen Afridi among first 15 overseas draft for Big Bash League 2025

Housefull 5 box office collection day 5: Akshay Kumar, Riteish Deshmukh, Abhishek Bachchan film races towards Rs 200-crore mark globally, earns Rs...

Delhi NCR Weather: Delhi records season's hottest day as temperature reaches...; IMD forecast says rain expected after THIS date

Amitabh Bachchan felt 'so bad' for doing a film with Aishwarya Rai, Vivek Oberoi: 'I don't get along with...'

RCB owners finally break silence over reports claiming sale of franchise after maiden IPL title win, says 'would like to clarify that...'

Meghalaya honeymoon murder case: In last phone call with mother, Raja Raghuvanshi said...

Aamir Khan reviews son Junaid Khan's performance in Maharaj, Loveyapa: 'He doesn't know how to..., he can't....'

Fertility rate declines amid population hitting 1.46 billion in India, UN says answer lies in...

Anil Ambani's company signs big Rs 10000 crore defence pact with German firm, set to manufacture...

‘Never posted...’: Elon Musk dismisses his AI chatbot Grok’s remarks sparking controversy alleging him stealing...

8 friends on picnic drown while taking bath in river in Rajasthan, 3 rescued

CONFIRMED! Australia, South Africa reveal Playing XI for WTC Final 2025: Check inside

Rs 200,000 for donkeys! Chinese obsession behind disappearance of lakhs of this animal because...

Viral Video: Apple Store, Jordan Flagship store looted in Los Angeles amid anti-ICE protest, WATCH

Delhi Cabinet takes BIG decision on school fee hike, govt to impose...; check details

Mumbai-Nagpur Expressway: Travel time reduced to just 8 hrs, check toll prices, speed limits and more

Remember Ali Haji? Aamir Khan, Kajol's son in Fanaa, worked in Salman Khan's Partner; here's how handsome he looks now

From CWC 2015 to 2023 World Cup: A look at unbeaten trio of Cummins, Hazlewood and Starc ahead of WTC 2025 Final

Hospital meal shocks patient which came with...; video goes viral

Meet man who studied at IIT Kanpur, worked closely with Ratan Tata for decades, his salary is Rs 265000000, now leads company worth Rs...

BIG blow to Pakistan? China may join hands with India after THIS country takes initiative

Where to Buy Clenbuterol Online in 2025 — Fast US Shipping & Smart Savings

Strawberry Moon 2025: When and how to watch this rare celestial event in India, know tips for best view

Google launches new special feature in Gemini amid ChatGPT global outage; check eligibility, details here

Pawan Kalyan, Bobby Deol-starrer Hari Hara Veera Mallu to not hit theatres this Friday, new release date...

Netherlands’ museum displays 200-year-old condom, a 19th century satire on... with a sharp message in unique exhibition titled...

Kwikpic’s AI Technology Redefining the Way Event and Wedding Photos Are Shared

Anil Ambani's company's shares hit fresh high of Rs...; market cap now reaches Rs...

Meet actress, who became star at 16, worked with Rajinikanth, Mohanlal, Mammootty, died by suicide at 34 after...

WATCH: Monkey kisses goodbye to caretaker at his funeral, heartwarming video goes viral

Shah Rukh Khan and Gauri Khan rent flat for household staff for monthly rent of...., its located in..

All you need to know about Coronavirus: Origin, discovery, carriers, what can it do to humans, WHO says...

Deepika Padukone makes big announcement after leaving Prabhas, Sandeep Reddy Vanga's Spirit for Allu Arjun, Atlee's film: 'I've experienced firsthand...'

ChatGPT down: Several users unable to access AI chatbot, say, 'No model is working'

The sleep crisis India isn’t talking about— A nation awake is a nation at risk

After leading CSK in IPL 2025, Ruturaj Gaikwad to head to England to join...

Karan Johar breaks his silence on feud with Kartik Aaryan, removing him from Dostana 2: 'He and I...'

Thug Life box office collection day 5: Kamal Haasan, Mani Ratnam film crashes on first Monday, earns just Rs...

Plutus Education Launches DIBO: Building Talent for a Booming Investment Banking Operations Market

Delhi NCR weather update: IMD issues Red Alert as heatwave scorches city, rain expected on...

Meet star who helped Shah Rukh Khan when he was struggling, offered him food; his name is...

Good news for Gautam Adani as Adani Power shares over 6%, market cap climbs to Rs...

Australia vs South Africa: What happens if WTC Final gets washed out or ends in draw or tie?

Meet Hollywood's richest man who has net worth over Rs 71,730 crore, not Tom Cruise, The Rock, his name is....

Austria: At least 9 dead, several injured after shooting rampage at school