Coronavirus could turn cities into doughnuts: empty centres but vibrant suburbs

The most recent COVID-19 lockdowns were accompanied by sobering news from the UK’s high streets. The Arcadia Group, which owns some of the UK’s most iconic high street clothing retail

outlets – Topshop, Topman and Dorothy Perkins, among others – has gone into administration. Meanwhile, the UK’s oldest retail chain, Debenhams, is closing. Around 12,000 people are set to

lose their jobs, on top of 6,500 already lost this year, after efforts to rescue the retailer fell through. All of this comes at the end of a decade that saw a major decline of British high

streets. Since 2007, some 556 retail companies have failed, with the closure of almost 39,100 stores and the loss of 468,809 jobs as shoppers move online. These impacts vary geographically.

Many of the closures are concentrated in city centres. But beyond the city core, there remains the prospect that smaller town centres and suburban high streets might emerge stronger in 2021

as people learn to love shopping locally again. A DOWNWARDS TREND Long before the pandemic, high street retailers were facing stiff competition from out-of-town shopping centres and, more

importantly, online retailing. According to the UK’s Office for National Statistics, online sales in November 2006 totalled 2.8% of all retail sales. The latest data shows that online sales

in October 2020 amounted to 28.1% of total retail sales – but this had already risen to 21.5% in November 2019, before COVID-19 reached the UK. The pandemic has exacerbated the downwards

slide of high streets. Thousands of the shops closed in March 2020 have not reopened. But there are markedly different patterns from town to town. Local high streets with more convenience

shopping, hot food takeaways and other essential businesses have generally performed much better than city centres dominated by department stores and shops selling higher-value items. Take

Greater Manchester, for example. Google’s Community Mobility data shows that visitor numbers to retail and recreation spaces in smaller town centres like Bury and Rochdale have recovered

faster. In contrast, Manchester city centre has continued to perform much more poorly as commuters continue to work at home and avoid public transport. It may actually be that COVID-19 has

encouraged more people to shop locally, and that they have begun to see more value in their local town centres. This raises a fundamental question about the future of city centre retailing.

London provides a good example. Now that the first COVID vaccine has been approved by the UK government, central London will undoubtedly eventually return to some of its former vitality,

attracting tourists and other visitors to enjoy its eclectic night-time economy, theatres, galleries and museums. But, if more people prefer to work at home and not head into central London

from the suburbs, the retail retraction we have witnessed in 2020 will only worsen. HOLLOW CITIES Retail and recreation visitor numbers in central London – the City of Westminster and the

City of London – have been particularly affected by COVID-19 when compared to the wider city. Overall average daily visitor numbers to retail and recreation spaces within Westminster and the

City of London fell by 70.6% and 76.7% respectively between February 15 and November 24 2020. The most recent lockdown, which commenced on November 5, saw retail and recreation visitor

numbers fall to 90%-92% below pre-COVID levels. In comparison, overall average retail and recreation visitor numbers in inner London and outer London councils were down by 54.9% and 38.4%

respectively. Our mapping of the impact of COVID-19 on visitor journeys to retail and recreation places across London effectively reveals a “doughnut city”: shoppers have abandoned the

centre, while suburbs have remained rather more resilient. The future of city centre high streets after COVID-19 is uncertain. One answer would be to suggest the cities will bounce back as

vaccinated workers and shoppers return, and that their shopping streets will live on. However, this does not take into account the scars left by COVID-19. Take London’s iconic Oxford Street

as an example. Since late March, department store John Lewis has halved the size of its Oxford Street store. House of Fraser, another department store, is to be part-repurposed as offices

and a gym. Topshop’s flagship store on the street is at risk of closure. With online retail behemoth Amazon emerging as one of the only winners of COVID-19, we have to be realistic about the

future of central London as a shopping hub. Retail rents are declining fast in the West End, and it is likely that prime retail sites will be converted to offices or even homes. The UK

government has already loosened planning regulations that permits the conversion of shops to residential uses without planning permission – all part of the drive to solve the housing crisis.

We are witnessing a switch in the use of urban space, as people working from home increasingly spend time, and money, outside city centres. The hope is that smaller high streets and those

local centres most valued as hubs of community life, not just places of consumption, will witness a renaissance in 2021. The viability of larger centres – Birmingham, Manchester, and

especially London – looks to have fundamentally unravelled.